How To Negotiate A Settlement Agreement

colin freeman headshot

A settlement agreement is a legally binding contract that resolves workplace disputes or formalises the end of employment on mutually consented terms. It typically involves the employee giving up legal claims in return for compensation. When you negotiate a settlement agreement, you can shape the outcome, be it the compensation, notice, or other terms, to better suit your needs.

1. Know You Have the Right — Don’t Just Accept

You’re not required to accept the first offer. You can negotiate terms like compensation, restrictive covenants, notice pay, and even additional benefits or wording. Be careful: a counteroffer may count as rejecting the original offer.

2. Avoid Resigning Too Soon

Don’t resign before sorting the settlement. Resigning can harm your negotiating position and reduce your chances for fair compensation, or may even mean none at all.

3. Understand Your Employer’s Motives

Employers generally want a quick, cost-effective resolution and to avoid negative publicity or tribunal claims. Knowing this can guide your negotiation strategy.

4. Balance Ambition with Realism

While aiming high can yield better outcomes, being unrealistic can stall talks. Working with an employment law specialist can help you strike the right tone.

5. Be Clear About What You Want

Decide your priorities, financial uplift, reference wording, limiting restrictive clauses, and focus your negotiation on them.

6. Legal Advice Is Essential

A settlement agreement isn’t legally binding in the UK unless you receive independent legal advice from an appropriately qualified advisor (like a solicitor). Employers commonly cover these fees.

7. Typical Timeline for Negotiations

There’s no fixed timeline; it depends on the complexity of the case. However, you will typically have at least 10 days to consider the agreement after receiving it. Solicitors help expedite this process while ensuring you understand the terms.

At-a-Glance: Negotiation Checklist

Step Action Why It Matters
1 Review the initial offer thoroughly Know what you’re being asked to agree to and what rights are being waived.
2 Identify your priorities This shapes your counteroffer, i.e., compensation, notice, and references.
3 Engage a specialist solicitor Ensures you know if the offer is fair and legally sound.
4 Submit a reasoned counteroffer Opens meaningful negotiation without rejecting outright.
5 Evaluate the revised offer If it meets your priorities, that’s good; if not, consult and reassess.
6 Finalize with legal certification Once signed, the agreement is binding and enforceable.

Why Negotiating a Settlement Agreement Makes Sense

  • Avoid tribunals: Settlement negotiations are faster, more confidential, and less stressful than going to an employment tribunal.
  • Gain certainty: You control the outcome instead of a tribunal deciding.
  • Potentially higher payout: You may secure better compensation than standard redundancy terms.

Ready to Negotiate Your Settlement Agreement

Negotiating a settlement agreement can dramatically affect your future, financially and professionally.

Next Steps:

Your path to a fair, well-negotiated settlement agreement starts here.

 

colin freeman headshot
Author Colin Freeman View Profile
Colin qualified as a solicitor in 1998. He specialises predominantly in family law, litigation / dispute resolution, wills, probate and settlement agreements and has notable cases reported in the Court of Appeal and High Court.
boardroom view through glasses

Book Your Free, No-Obligation 20-Minute Consultation Today!

"*" indicates required fields

When is the best time to call?*